Election evening started with concern for Rep. Sean Patrick Maloney’s supporters, who gathered at Nyack Seaport for a victory celebration with the chairman of the Democratic Campaign Committee.
Maloney, nonetheless, had failed to indicate up after deciding to fly to Washington, DC to supervise the committee’s response to what pundits have been predicting could be widespread casualties, as a purple wave swept throughout the nation. That wave by no means peaked, and Democrats have been nonetheless clinging to Thursday’s hope that sufficient of the 30-tie races would discover their means.
But Maloney, D-Cold Spring, whose consideration was divided between his personal marketing campaign and the nationwide effort to avoid wasting the House majority that fall, was swept apart within the Hudson Valley. He was one in every of 4 seats within the New York Congress to modify from a Democrat to a Republican.
He narrowly misplaced by 2,800 votes — simply 1% — to Rep. Mike Lawler, the media-savvy Pearl River political adviser who used his abilities to enlist others for a two-year time period in Congress in a district whose constituents ranked Democrat Joe Biden within the 2020 had given a bonus of 10%.
The cash spent on the race was staggering, with as much as $20 million going principally to unbiased political motion committees.
Lawler: Promise to seek out bipartisan options in Congress
Red Wave: Didn’t hit the Hudson Valley, however Republicans are making features
Governor’s Race: Hochul surpasses Zeldin
Lawler’s victory demonstrated the facility of his crime-fighting messages, the energy of the shifting orthodox Jewish voices in Rockland, and the vitality of the brand new era of Republican leaders within the Hudson Valley. In his declaration of victory in New City, Lawler, 36, was joined by younger aspiring GOP officers, additionally 17th District: Yorktown Supervisor Matt Slater, 36, was elected to the State Assembly, and Rep. Kevin Byrne, 37, who was unopposed within the Putnam District Executive race.
“There’s a new generation rising,” stated Westchester County Republican Chairman Doug Colety.
Westchester Democratic Chairwoman Suzanne Berger acknowledged that Slater’s political group in north Westchester and Putnam County, within the coronary heart of the district’s Westchester GOP base, helped enhance Lawler’s outcomes. Rep. Lee Zeldin’s robust displaying in his suburban gubernatorial race additionally helped Lawler, she stated.
“The combination of Zeldin and Slater made it difficult in this district,” Berger stated.
Lawler ‘listened to our wants’
Lawler’s victory underscored the energy of Rockland Republicans. In a district the place Democrats outnumber registered Republicans about 2-to-1, Lawler gained 56% of the vote, with the Rockland GOP additionally serving to Bill Weber oust state Senator Elijah Reichlin-Melnick.
Lawler addressed complaints about points that aren’t widespread fodder for a federal workplace race. He railed in opposition to New York State’s bail reform legal guidelines and piggybacked on Zeldin’s anti-crime message. He additionally pledged to deal with the issues of oldsters whose views on training aren’t being revered by training officers.
Monsey resident Rivkie Feiner, a member of the Rockland Orthodox congregation, stated Lawler gained the congregation’s belief throughout his two years within the state meeting together with his positions on college selection, yeshiva formation and his issues about inflation.
Maloney did properly with the ultra-Orthodox vote in New Square, however rising turnout from voters like Feiner, whose kids attend native yeshivas, proved necessary to Lawler’s victory.
“He listened to our needs and paid attention to them,” she stated. “And our congregation came out to vote. A community that votes is a community that is heard.”
The Rockland Police Officers have been an necessary a part of Lawler’s victorious coalition as his anti-crime message resonated with these working in public security. Larry Ayers, president of the Rockland County Police Department’s Benevolent Association, put it bluntly, “Mike was 100% supportive of the blue.”
New strains modified the stability
The redistribution additionally damage Maloney.
Under new tips authorised by the state Legislature, Westchester’s three congressmen — Maloney, Rep. Jamaal Bowman, D-Yonkers and Mondaire Jones, D-White Plains — all stayed within the districts the place they lived. But these strains have been invalidated by a state decide, leaving the choice to an neutral courtroom grasp.
Maloney’s district was cut up in two, with 30% of his previous district within the seventeenthth, with the remaining 70% of the borough being offered by Jones, who ended up dwelling in Bowman’s borough. Maloney selected the seventeenththtogether with Rockland County, the place Jones grew up, and he was little identified.
Rockland was additionally Mike Lawler’s political base, which he labored exhausting to construct throughout his first tenure at Albany.
“The Democratic Party brought this on itself with an ill-fated redistricting plan that wasn’t ready for prime time,” stated Paul Adler, former Rockland County Democrat chairman. “Humpty Dumpty couldn’t put all the pieces back together.”
Much to the chagrin of native progressives, Jones determined to maneuver to Brooklyn as a result of he did not need to go to elementary college for both Maloney or Bowman.
Democrats weren’t ‘tremendous impressed’
To make issues worse for Maloney, state senator Alessandra Biaggi, one in every of Westchester’s progressives, took motion in opposition to him, who argued that Maloney was too average for at this time’s Democrats. Maloney and a political motion committee funded largely by actual property pursuits insisted that Biaggi’s requires police reform for the suburban space had gone too far.
Maloney beat Biaggi greater than 2 to 1, however that left many progressives discouraged. Biaggi’s look with Maloney at a unity gathering wasn’t sufficient to energise activists like Kenny Herzog, a Democratic district chief of Sleepy Hollow.
“It was a foregone conclusion that Westchester could push Maloney over the top,” stated Herzog, a Sleepy Hollow Democratic district chief who championed Biaggi. “But folks had ambivalences. Everyone needs to really feel impressed, and plenty of Democrats in Westchester and Rockland have not been significantly impressed.”
Follow David McKay Wilson on Twitter @davidmckay415.
Subscribers can join his weekly e-newsletter. Read his columnns within the archives of lohud.com.